Virginia on the batch plant permit and what you can do

With Doug Udell leading the way and Jerry Scott seconding the motions,
Suwannee County Commissioners voted to DENY WITHOUT PREJUDICE
Suwannee/American's request to grant a temporary permit for the batch plant
which could build the Suwannee/American Cement Kiln near the Ichetucknee
State Park.
    I read the following letter; Paul Gibbs acted as quasi-lawyer as Suwannee
County Lawyer tried to convince Commissioners to vote to approve the plan.
Representative Bob Casey and Gainesville City Commissioner Bruce Delaney
attended the hearing, while Senator Richard Mitchell and House candidate
Harvey Budd offered support by telephone.
    When Commissioner Udell moved to table the decision until S/A had all of
its permits, Suwannee/American's lawyer whispered in the County Attorney's
ear something.  An irate audience called out, "What did you say?"  The lawyer
turned around to the audience and said, "I simply said, if you delay this
vote beyond election day, a different County Commission may be sitting here.
S/A will have to start all over again."
    Ralph Ashodian asked each County Commissioner, "Did you receive any
contributions or gifts from Joe Anderson or from any of his employees?"  All
Commissioners answered, "No."  Ashodian then asked Commissioners, "Have you
met in secret with any representatives of S/A or any of their other
companies?"  All except Jerry Scott answered, "No."  Jerry Scott said, "Not
on this matter."
    The motion to table the vote was defeated 3/2, with Udell and Scott
voting to table.  Barry Baker made a motion to grant the permit with the
reservation that no other permit granting body can take what Udell called the
"host county's approval" (Suwannee County) of the permit into consideration
when granting approval of any other permits.  That motion died without a
second.
    S/A's lawyer tried to cut off opponents, such as Engineer Dave Bruderly,
while they listened to Suwannee County's lawyer back S/A.  The audience
screamed in protest.  Next the County Lawyer advised the Commission to vote
the issue either up or down.  The County Lawyer twice told Commissioner Udell
that he had to give a reason for his motion to table, then when that motion
died, he insisted that Udell give not one, but two reasons to deny the
permit.  Udell stated at least seven times: "I want the cement kiln; I want
the batch plant.  What I'm confused about is why S/A is asking for this
permit BEFORE all permits are granted from the State.  Why do you have the
cart before the horse?  I think you are trying to use us to gain other
permits."  Udell gave as a further reason to deny the permit, "The land use
is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan."   Citizen Paul Gibbs
continually interrupted the proceedings, calling for fairness.  The opponents
had no lawyer present.
    The letter I read follows:
May 13, 2000

Dear Suwannee County Commissioner Donald Odom,
    I am writing to you for the second time in the past 18 months, expressing
my concern for your well being.  First I asked you not to allow an industrial
site, the Suwannee/American Cement Kiln, to be placed near the Ichetucknee
River State Park for reasons of polluting noise, toxins, and traffic.  I
represent over 10,000 people in the State who wish this beautiful area of
North Florida could be preserved as part of the Old Florida, the Real Florida.
    While we understand that small rural counties must provide roads,
schools, medical, and other services for their citizens, we know that a
well-developed plan to expand eco-tourism, retirement villages, and
agricultural activities could provide many more jobs while leaving the
environment relatively natural.
    My concern directly affects you and your current decision on the
Temporary Batch Plant site approval scheduled for May 18th.  My concern for
you results from the fate of many politicians who have fallen under the
influence of Joe Anderson and his companies.  As you are no doubt aware,
Vice-president of the Senate, Bo Johnson, and Senator Randy Mackey are both
in prison for doing favors for Joe Anderson and not reporting the money they
received.  You must know that Judge Sartin has recused himself from any
further dealings with the Suwannee/American cement kiln issue, because he
feels his inside dealings with either Governor Bush and/or Joe Anderson have
tainted his opinion.  Further, Governor Bush, who has received over $150,000
in campaign contributions from Joe Anderson, has changed his mind about the
air permit; he delegated his authority to Secretary Struhs.  Now even DEP
Secretary Struhs has recused himself from making the decision on the air
permit.
The people of Florida and of the United States want clean government; they do
not like government out of the sunshine.  More and more, the people are
demanding that industry be clean, and above all, that industry preserve the
little remaining natural land areas, such as in North Florida.
But, most important is the fact that you are already under suspicion for your
dealings with Joe Anderson.  The people of Florida are so furious that their
clean rivers and air are being destroyed for money and greed. The Ichetucknee
Experience is in jeopardy. They are calling for investigations.  People who
make deals with Joe Anderson end up in jail, or at least out of public life.
Joe Anderson continues to do business as usual in Florida, but politicians
who make secret deals with him are going to jail.
I caution you to do business in the sunshine, and to vote in the best
interest of the citizens of not only Suwannee County, but of Columbia County,
and all the Floridians who use the three rivers which will be affected by the
cement kiln.  The Batch Plant is being built for only one reason: to build
Joe Anderson's cement kiln.  If you are at all nervous about being
investigated concerning your dealings concerning this issue already, good
advice would be to vote against the Batch Plant.
Other reasons to vote against the Batch Plant are that it will use precious
water in our already drought-stressed region.  The aquifer not only feeds the
springs and rivers, but of course, it provides drinking water and irrigation
for the already-existing endeavors in the County.  In questioning before the
Plan Board, Suwannee/American representatives could not answer how much water
will be used, but they confirmed that the water will come from wells, of
course.
A Greenway is being prepared right across from the Batch Plant site, on Route
27, to connect Branford and High Springs.  The A/C representative did not
even know the existence of his eco-tourist path for biking, jogging, and
walking.  This spring 400 bicycle riders spent money in North Florida's
campsites, restaurants, and motels.  Visitors to natural areas do not come to
sites which are industrialized, because they are noisy and polluting.  The
Batch Plant will interfere with eco-tourism.  Many, many more jobs are at
stake in the agriculture/eco-tourist industry than will be gained from the
construction of a cement kiln and a batch plant.
The A/C representative requesting site approval for the Batch Plant did not
know how much cement would be delivered to the site, but he guessed it would
come from Brooksville.  The truck route will be over Route 27 from the East,
increasing dangerous cement-truck traffic on the same road that visitors use
for the State Park.  Not only will the cement kiln add hundreds of trucks
along this sensitive two-land road, but the Batch Plant will run truckload
after noisy, dangerous truckload of cement between the site and the kiln.
A/C said the trucks cannot travel over the Anderson-owned land, because a
mine lies in between the Batch Plant and the kiln site.  This traffic will be
continuous, noisy, and dangerous.
I do not envy you.  In Bagdad, Florida, and in Cross City, Florida, citizens
rue the day they did business with Joe Anderson.  Some of them are in jail.
You began a bad business here, and I urge you to vote no to the Batch Plant.
Your every move will be investigated, because many of the people of Florida
do not want to see North Florida go the way of South and West Florida.  We
want State Parks, not Industrial Parks.

Sincerely yours,
 

Virginia Seacrist
SICK, Chairperson

If you have any questions about this event, please call Virginia Seacrist,
904=497=4471.
 
 
 

If you want to do something to Stop the Ichetucknee Cement Kiln, please
telephone the Suwannee County Commissioners and thank them for considering
the citizen's who oppose Joe Anderson and a cement kiln in Suwannee County.
I telephoned them today and they were grateful to be appreciated for taking a
stand against the Batch Plant.  We must encourage the commissioners to
continue to re-evaluate their stand on the cement kiln, although the
commission in no way denied that they want the cement kiln.
    Jerry Scott 904-362-4955
    Douglas Udell 904-362-4189
    Barry Baker 904-776-2285
    Robert Taylor 904-963-4138
    Donald Odom 904-935-1647
    The important facts are that Commissioner Udell reiterated that the
Commission's granting of a permit prematurely might be a tactic S/A is using
to gain other permits.  Udell adamantly stated that he does not want to be use
d.  Udell was encouraged to give as a second reason for denial; he stated
that the Batch Plant in an agricultural area is an improper land use.  If a
batch plant is improper use, what can a cement kiln be?
    Bob Casey, Bruce Delaney, Richard Mitchell, Cynthia Chestnut, Harvey
Budd, Rod Smith, John Koch, Bob Butterworth, Bill Nelson, Janegale Boyd have
all telephoned me with their concerns about the Ichetucknee Cement Kiln.
Call these candidates/elected officials and tell them you want to vote for
candidates who come out against the S/A kiln.  Also, ask officials to contact
Struhs and Bush, telling them to consider that the citizens are coming out
against the kiln locally. Bush has said he wants this issue settled locally.
    Further, since Assistant Secretary of DEP Lisa Edgars
(lisa.edgars@dep.state.fl.us 850-488-2960) has been designated as the person
who will make the air permit decision, contact her to tell her not to grant
the permit to Joe Anderson, whose record of non-compliance with regulations
is scandalous.  Bush's original reason for denial still stands.
    Encourage any contacts you have with the National presidential campaigns
to discuss the environment, using Florida's scandalous handling of the
Ichetucknee issue as a symbol that we need more attention to saving the
environment.
Virginia Seacrist
SICK, Chairperson